Evidential force of religious experience oxford scholarship. Sep 28, 1989 this study examines the nature of religious experiences and whether they can be used as evidence for religious beliefs. The twentieth century saw significant new developments in and significant new directions for the treatments of religious experience and religious epistemology. This study examines the nature of religious experiences and whether they can be used as evidence for religious beliefs. Nov 20, 2019 a companion to philosophy of religion blackwell, 1997, pp. Find a summary of this and each chapter of the varieties of religious experience. Religious reform in a sixteenthcentury city teresa of avila and the rhetoric of femininity jodi bilinkoff and alison weber gillian t. Open library is an initiative of the internet archive, a 501c3 nonprofit, building a digital library of internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. This clearly presented study examines the nature of religious experiences, and asks whether they can be used as evidence for religious beliefs. The evidential force of religious experience lexile find a. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The argument from religious experience is an argument for the existence of god. A monastic tradition may emphasize the devotional aspects of everyday. The evidential force of religious experience philpapers.
Definition of religious experience a religious experience is a nonempirical occurrence, and may be perceived as supernatural. The religious experience of saint paul internet archive. The varieties of religious experience lecture 1 summary. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. The author addresses philosophical issues such as the role of models and read more. A religious experiencereligious experience has been argued to be ground for belief ingod. Various reasons have been offered for and against accepting this contention. Download the bookshelf mobile app at or from the itunes or android store to access your ebooks from your mobile device or ereader. The philosophical discussions in these areas have now taken on significant new dimensions. Philosophy of religion pdf book manual free download.
Add this ebook to your cart, purchase it and download it immediately in any or all of these formats. The evidential force of religious experience caroline. The evidential problem of evil points to the incontrovertible evidence of evil in the world. Buy the evidential force of religious experience new ed by davis, caroline franks isbn. Chapter summary for william jamess the varieties of religious experience, lecture 1 summary. Franks davis, caroline the evidential force of religious experience 1989. The religious experience of saint paul by gardner, percy, 18461937. It was his campfollowers who took it up to do service for schleiermachers notion of religion as a feeling of absolute dependence. Religious experience refers to the moment in which a believer has a revelation from god or another religious figure.
This book provides an assessment of the value of religious experiences as evidence for religious beliefs. Dec 01, 2000 read american psychology of religion and the journal for the scientific study of religion, journal for the scientific study of religion on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. It comprises his edited gifford lectures on natural theology, which were delivered at the university of edinburgh, scotland between 1901 and 1902. The evidential force of religious experience kindle. Read online philosophy of religion book pdf free download link book now. Davis, caroline franks, the evidential force of religious experience clarendon, 1989 is a book devoted to the topic of religious experience.
Pdf empirical psychologys philosophy of science traditionally orients by poppers critical rationalism. The varieties of religious experience lectures 4 and 5. Jan 05, 2012 sense perception, especially vision, is vivid and richly detailed, bursting with information, whereas experience of god is dim, meager, and obscure. Apart from conversations with god, religious experiences include miracles and other hardtoexplain phenomena. With all the more traditional avenues of theisms defense generally in disrepute, modern theologians and religious philosophers have repeatedly sought to justify religious belief rationally by reference to the individuals experience.
A religious experience sometimes known as a spiritual experience, sacred experience, or mystical experience is a subjective experience which is interpreted within a religious framework. The concept originated in the 19th century, as a defense against the growing rationalism of western society. Jakobsens pioneering work on the accounts of experiences of evil held in the rerc archive. And 2 does testimony about such experiences provides any justification for believing that there is a god for those who are not the subject of the experience.
Neuroscientific explanations of religious experience are not free from cultural aspects. The rationality of belief and the plurality of faith on jstor. A phenomenal conservative perspective on religious experience. When dealing with happiness and the benefits of spiritual experience p.
It holds that the best explanation for religious experiences is that they constitute genuine experience or perception of a divine reality. The evidential force of religious experience lexile. The evidential force of religious experience paperback. Philosophy of religion is the philosophical examination of the themes and.
Download philosophy of religion book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf. The evidential force of religious experience hardcover. How did and does people experience, mystically or otherwise, religion and the divine and how does these experiences influence religion, history and life in general. The philosophy of religion reader 1st edition chad. Subjectrelated challenges may initially seem less damaging than the objectrelated. The author discusses important philosophical issues raised by religious. Dermot mcdonald, what is meant by religious experience. Can religious experience provide justification for the belief in god. The evidential force of religious experience caroline franks davis on amazon. The term religious experience can conjure up a wide and diverse series of images.
Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Traditional religion is a better choice since it commonly contains religious experience. Philosophy of religion stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. With over 40,000 copies in print since its original publication in 1982, steve evanss philosophy of religion has served many generations of students as a classic introduction to the philosophy of religion from a christian perspective. Chapter summary for william jamess the varieties of religious experience, lectures 4 and 5 summary. Douglas geivett the evidential value of religious experience part 8, the problem of evil 50. The incompatibility between free will theodicies and. The giving of moral benefits in religious experience acts to undermine the second purpose we are said to have been given free will and hence generates the incompatibility between free will theodicies and religious experience. Not only does it give a complete catalog of the various types of religious experiences, but it also gives a complete catalog of the various arguments from religious experience and the objections that. This article outlines an analytical framework that enables analysis of degrees of democracy in a school or other organizational setting. A study in human nature is a book by harvard university psychologist and philosopher william james.
However, our understanding of the term is important in investigating the concept. Sense perception is shared by all human beings, whereas the experience of god. But in the seventeenth century at least to someone from the tropics, the same testimony is and should be much less. Experience religion, conversion publisher new york, the abingdon press collection princeton. Some scholars have responded to the apparent differences between monistic and theistic mysticisms by emphasizing the role of socio religious interpretations of the experiences. It is a principle of rationality that in the absence. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
The varieties of religious experience summary four. The book examines mysticism and ways to understand what goes on in religious experiences, helping us to understand whether it is good grounds for religious belief. Much more than an argument from religious experience, the inquiry systematically addresses underlying philosophical issues such as therole of interpretation in experience, the function of models and metaphors in religious language, and the way perceptual experiences in general are used as evidence for claims about the world. The socalled argument from religious experience plays a prominent role in todays analytical. I religious experience and womens experience the subtitle of my presentation bears what someone might recognise as a certain, perhaps misleading resemblance to caroline franks davis book the evidential force of religious experience. Caroline franks davis, the evidential force of religious. It can be described as a mental event which is undergone by an individual, and of which that person is aware. This site is like a library, you could find million book here by using search box in the header. Miracles and evidential probability 41 testimony about a man walking on a frozen pond in december in england is in conformity with their own knowledge and experience, and the testimony is therefore to be judged credible by them.
The author argues that religious language in both christian and buddhist traditions is intelligible as factual discourse, and so reports of mystical experience are true or false. Proponents of arguments from religious experience often succumb to the demand to provide a brief, precise definition of religious experience. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. Caroline franks davis provides a clear, sensitive, and carefully argued assessment of the value of religious experiences as evidence for religious beliefs. The evidential force of religious experience caroline franks davis on. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it.
The notion of religious experience can be traced back to william james, who used the term religious experience in his book, the varieties of religious experience. The epistemology of religious experience book, 1993. Such an experience can be spontaneous, or it may be brought about as a result of intensive. Should be the starting point for any future investigation of the evidential force of religious experience upon any particular religious claim. Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. Pdf religious experience and the probability of theism. Pdf selfevident spiritual experience and empirical. We best approach this question by splitting it in two. Can religious experience provide justification for the.
Much more than an argument from religious experience, the. Unlike, for instance, an inferential argument from religious experience, it is not a form of evidence or argument whose merits or demerits can be scrutinized by believers and non. In this paper, i br iefly trace how the argument from religious. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the evidential force of religious experience. Going further than an argument from religious experience, the inquiry systematically addresses underlying philosophical issues such as the role of interpretation in experience, the function of models and metaphors in religious language, and the way perceptual experiences in general.
Openmindedness and religious devotion springerlink. Keith yandell, richard swinburne, jerome gellman, kaiman kwan, caroline franksdavis, paul moser, and others have contributed to the current discussion about the topic. They included caroline daviss the evidential force of religious experience 1989, george walls religious experience and religious belief 1995, and jerome gellmans experience of god and the rationality of theistic belief1997. Publication date 19, c1911 topics paul, the apostle, saint. The author discusses important philosophical issues raised by religious experience, such as the role of models and metaphors in their description, andthe way experiences in general are used as evidence for claims about the world. See more ideas about religious experience, editorial fashion and fashion photography.
The argument from religious experience hereafter referred to as argument from re has seen a resurgence in scholarly work. Apr 12, 2014 evidential force and value the evidential value of religious experiences clark, 1984 the evidential force of religious experience davis, 1989 the evidential value of religious experience swinburne, 1981 evidential force. It is considered to be the classic work in the field, and references to james ideas are common at professional conferences. Much more than an argument from religious experience, the inquiry systematically. Ill be honest, some of the jargon, possibly due to the age of the varieties of religious experience had me a little lost at times. Objections commonly raised against reliance on religious experience become irrelevant on a nondoxastic approach. Although selfevident experiences like love, hate, empathy, or wisdom are not instantly replicable, cannot be easily communicated, and are prone to deception, such phenomena. To widen the definition to include all experiences referred to as religious would be foolhardy, since people often use terms such as religious and mystical metaphorically, to refer to any experience which is overwhelming.
Religious experience stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. A study of the nature of religious experience which discusses whether it can be used as evidence for religious beliefs. As long as the veridicality of such experience remains an epistemic possibility, it should guide our nondoxastic commitment. The author discusses important philosophical issues raised by. Theologians make the distinction between religious experiences and paranormal phenomena. The core of yandell\s argument concerns the formulation and application of. He contends that social science and other nonreligious explanations of religious belief and experience do not cancel out the evidential force of religious experience. Much more than an argument from religous experience, the inquiry systematically addresses underlying philosophical issues such as the role of interpretation in experience, the function of models and metaphors in religious language, and. List of books and articles about religious experience.
Religious experience, its evidential value by mains, george preston, 18441930. Regardless, this book will have me thinking some powerful deep thoughts for a while. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. A comparative doxasticpractice epistemology of religious. Religious experience and the probability of theism. This is usually combined with arguments to show that there is a similarity between sense experiences and religious ones that make them both worth applying the principle of credulity to. Religious experience, it will be argued, usually, if not always, gives recipients of religious experience moral benefits. Religious experience and religious epistemology springerlink. For some helpful work on the role of interpretation in religious experience, see caroline frank daviss the evidential force of religious experience, chap. Religious experience, its evidential value internet archive. A religious experience which succumbs to a subjectrelated challenge may well be veridical, then, but it cannot be used as evidence in an argument from religious experience. Not associated with any school or group, not the organ of any association or institution, it is interested in persistent, resolute inquiries into root questions, regardless of the writers affiliations. Going further than an argument from religious experience, the inquiry systematically addresses underlying philosophical issues such as the role of interpretation in experience, the function of models and metaphors in religious language, and the way perceptual experiences.
He then poses the question about what might qualify as a religious experience. Dec 23, 2015 i then offer a phenomenal conservative perspective on the epistemology of religious experience suggesting a categorically affirmative answer to 1 but a nuanced answer to 2 which allows the possibility of reasonable disagreement about religious experience. Charles darwin in 1876 remarked on the prevalence of this strategy. It is founded in a holistic conception of democracy, which is a model of working together that aspires to truth, goodness, and meaning and the participation of all. It is a sense of conviction, a sense of certitude, which has felt evidential force only for those who enjoy it and who firmly believe its source to be god. Swinburne formulates his account of the evidential force of religious.
In order to gain a much better understanding of religious experiences than a short definition ever could, this chapter considers a workable idea of what counts as a religious experience and looks at borderline experiences which are not deemed religious. This book takes a theoretical enterprise in christian philosophy of religion and. Absolutely brilliant this book have a different approach to the history of religion. A sense of holiness and profundityit involves the whole person mind, emotions, values andrelationships. Since the turn of the millennium, western psychology has widened its scope. While this prompting may play an evidential role in terms of the experience or. Both monistic and theistic experiences, they point out, are described as wholly unlike normal sensory events. Pdf religious studies, faith, and the presumption of. One thing which has disappointed me on more than one occasion. The debate in contemporary analytic philosophy kaiman kwan hong kong baptist university abstract in recent analytic philosophy of religion, one hotly debated topic is the veridicality of religious experience. Read american psychology of religion and the journal for the scientific study of religion, journal for the scientific study of religion on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. The evidential force of religious experience kindle edition by caroline franks davis. The evidential force of religious experience, clarendon. James allows in the varieties that fox had genuine religious experiences.
If we assume that the experiences cannot be shown a priori to be defective somehow, and that religious language is intelligibleand if we do not make these assumptions, then the question of religious testimony doesnt even arisethen it must be because the evidential value of the experience is so small that it cannot survive transmission. Otto, that a religious experience is an experience wherein one is. William james popularised the concept many religious and mystical traditions see religious. The evidential force of religious experience by caroline. We might assume that it can mean anything from saying a prayer, to attending a service at a place of worship, to hearing the voice of god. The religious experience of mankind by ninian smart. This book is heavy on epistemology but gives religious experience short shrift. This study examines the nature of religious experiences and whether they can be. Alstons influence has been pervasive in many recent books in the philosophy of religion and epistemology. Finally, some non religious experiences may have religious significance. Davis discusses the important philosophical issues raised by religious experience, such as the role of models and metaphors in descriptions of religious experience, and the way experiences in general are used as evidence for claims about the world. The evidential force of religious experience book, 1989.
1232 391 1447 999 233 287 1317 1549 1164 414 1197 716 1134 1488 1071 1242 1149 1107 88 320 19 303 632 1108 147 120 523 1291 1224 292 1014 699 667 954